AG-2024.04-1392·hep-ph·cross-listed: nucl-th
Strongly vs. weakly coupled in-medium showers: energy stopping in large-$N_f$ QED
Authors
- Peter Arnold
- Omar Elgedawy
- Shahin Iqbal
Abstract
Inside a medium, showers originating from a very high-energy particle may develop via medium-induced splitting processes such as hard bremsstrahlung or pair production. During shower development, two consecutive splittings sometimes overlap quantum mechanically, so that they cannot be treated independently. Some of these effects can be absorbed into an effective value of a medium parameter known as $\hat q$. Previous calculations (with certain simplifying assumptions) have found that, after adjusting the value of $\hat q$, the leftover effect of overlapping splittings is quite small for purely gluonic large-$N_c$ showers but is very much larger for large-$N_f$ QED showers, at comparable values of $Nα$. Those works did not quite make for apples-to-apples comparisons: the gluon shower work investigated energy deposition from a gluon-initiated shower, whereas the QED work investigated charge-deposition from an electron-initiated shower. As a first step to tighten up the comparison, this paper investigates energy deposition in the QED case. Along the way, we develop a framework that should be useful in the future to explore whether the very small effect of overlapping splitting in purely gluonic showers is an artifact of having ignored quarks.
Submitted
29 April 20242 years ago
Version
v1
License
CC-BY-4.0
DOI
10.48550/arXiv.2404.19008
Summary
When high-energy particles shower inside a medium, quantum effects from overlapping splittings matter much more in QED than in gluon showers—but this new study shows the comparison wasn't quite fair, and investigates the QED case more carefully.
- Previous studies compared gluon showers to QED showers unfairly: one tracked energy deposition, the other tracked charge; this work puts them on equal footing by studying energy deposition in QED.
- The surprising result from earlier work—that overlapping splittings barely matter for gluons but matter a lot for QED—might partially reflect the apples-to-oranges comparison rather than a fundamental physics difference.
- The paper develops a new framework that could help settle whether quarks fundamentally change how shower overlaps behave, which matters for understanding how jets lose energy in hot nuclear matter.
curious · generated by claude-haiku-4-5
Chat with this PDF
Ask questions, probe assumptions, request a plain-English summary. Answers cite sections from the preprint itself.
Community
Questions and answers about this paper from other readers. No formal peer review — just a place to think out loud.