Does thermal leptogenesis in a canonical seesaw rely on initial memory?

Abstract

It is a common lore that in the thermal leptogenesis in the type-1 seesaw scenario with the conventional hierarchy of heavy right-handed neutrinos (RHNs), the CP violating, out-of-equilibrium decay of the lightest RHN ($N_1$) is the only relevant source of $B-L$ asymmetry. Any asymmetry produced by the heavier RHNs ($N_2$ and $N_3$) gets washed out by the lepton number violating processes mediated by $N_1$. In this paper, we examine this assumption comprehensively, considering decay and inverse decay processes as well as the inclusion of scatterings. We find that the above said assumption is true only if all the RHNs ($N_1, N_2$ and $N_3$) are in strong washout regime. However, we saw that, to satisfy the neutrino masses and mixing given by the low energy neutrino oscillation data, at most one of the RHNs can be in the weak washout regime. This leads to, if $N_1$ is in the weak washout regime, then the washout parameters of $N_2$ and $N_3$ can be chosen in such a way that the impact of $N_2$ and $N_3$ on the final $B-L$ asymmetry is relatively small. On the other hand, if $N_2$ or $N_3$ is in weak washout regime, then the asymmetry produced by them can affect the final $B-L$ asymmetry even if $N_1$ is in the strong washout regime, which we call the memory effect. We delineated the parameter space where the memory effect is significant.