AG-2025.04-820·physics.hist-ph·cross-listed: gr-qcmath-ph
Is spacetime curved? Assessing the underdetermination of general relativity and teleparallel gravity
Authors
- Ruward Mulder
- James Read
Abstract
Realism about general relativity (GR) seems to imply realism about spacetime curvature. The existence of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR) calls this into question, for (a) TEGR is set in a torsionful but flat spacetime, and (b) TEGR is empirically equivalent to GR. Knox (2011) claims that there is no genuine underdetermination between GR and TEGR; we call this verdict into question by isolating and addressing her individual arguments. In addition, we anticipate and evaluate two further worries for realism about the torsionful spacetimes of TEGR, which we call the "problem of operationalisability" and the "problem of visualisability".
Submitted
24 April 20251 year ago
Version
v1
License
CC-BY-4.0
DOI
10.48550/arXiv.2505.04632
Summary
Two formulations of gravity—Einstein's curved spacetime and teleparallel gravity's flat, twisted spacetime—make identical predictions, raising the question of whether spacetime curvature is real or just one mathematical choice among many.
- Teleparallel gravity achieves everything general relativity does using flat spacetime with torsion (twisting) instead of curvature, yet both theories pass the same experimental tests.
- This creates a philosophical puzzle: if two incompatible descriptions of spacetime's geometry are empirically indistinguishable, how can we claim one correctly describes reality?
- The paper challenges the idea that this ambiguity can be dismissed, arguing that torsion-based spacetime deserves serious consideration despite being harder to visualize and measure directly.
curious · generated by claude-haiku-4-5
Chat with this PDF
Ask questions, probe assumptions, request a plain-English summary. Answers cite sections from the preprint itself.
Community
Questions and answers about this paper from other readers. No formal peer review — just a place to think out loud.