Natural Panspermia to Earth: Quantitative Limits on Donor Classes, Transport, Survival, and Establishment

Abstract

Natural panspermia is a transport-and-establishment hypothesis, not a theory of abiogenesis. The Earth-specific question is whether any nonterrestrial donor remains competitive with terrestrial origin once launch, planetary-system escape, transit, Earth interception, atmospheric entry, terminal loading, and post-delivery establishment are imposed. We formulate this problem as a donor-class dependent Earth-directed transport-survival kernel, supplemented by a minimum protected-depth envelope \(d_{\min}(t_{\mathrm{fl}})\) and a survival-weighted buried-volume fraction \(\Fbur\) for the low-shock spall population. The resulting hierarchy is sharp. Hard panspermia is physically credible only on Solar-System scales: early Mars combines demonstrated lithic exchange with Earth, low escape speed, early aqueous habitability, and a rare \(10^{2}\)--\(10^{4}\,\mathrm{yr}\) transfer tail, whereas the more common \(10^{5}\)--\(10^{7}\,\mathrm{yr}\) martian transfer regime requires lightly shocked meter-class carriers. Beyond the Solar System, low-\(\vinf\) capture and long-duration survival fail simultaneously; even the Solar birth-cluster channel yields only \(\sim 3\times10^{-5} f_{\mathrm{seed}}\) expected Earth-seeding events, where \(f_{\mathrm{seed}}\) is the conditional probability that a viable arrival establishes life on Earth. Indigenous terrestrial origin therefore remains the default inference, early Mars is the only quantitatively serious external hard-panspermia alternative, and extrasolar or intergalactic hard panspermia is not competitive for Earth's actual origin history. Soft panspermia is much more plausible as chemical enrichment of early terrestrial abiogenesis.