Vector charmonium(-like) states in the energy range of 4.1-4.6 GeV

Abstract

The spectrum of vector charmonium(-like) states in the 4.1-4.6 GeV energy region exhibits a long-standing tension. While the inclusive $R$-value indicates the presence of only vector charmonia that are usually interpreted as conventional states, exclusive $e^+e^-$ cross sections reveal additional structures whose parameters strongly depend on the observed final states when fitted with Breit-Wigner functions. This puzzling pattern suggests that coupled-channel and threshold effects play an essential role. In this work, we develop a unified coupled-channel framework relevant for the $1^{--}$ resonances in the considered energy region. The framework incorporates the $S$-wave open-charm channels $D\bar{D}_1$, $D^*\bar{D}_1$, and $D^*\bar{D}_2^*$, constrained by heavy-quark spin symmetry, optional bare poles corresponding to quark-model states which may be associated with the $ψ(4160)$ and the $ψ(4415)$, and final-state interaction in the $Z_c$ channels relevant for the three-body final states. We employ several benchmark models based on the constructed framework to perform simultaneous fits to the BESIII data for the cross sections of $e^+e^-\to J/ψπ^+π^-$, $h_cπ^+π^-$, $D\bar{D}^*π$, $D^*\bar{D}^*π$, $J/ψη$, and $χ_{c0}ω$, together with the available invariant-mass distributions that exhibit the $Z_c(3900)$ and $Z_c(4020)$ structures. The models differ in the number of bare seed states and the fitting strategy. We show that even the purely dynamical scheme captures the gross features of all the analyzed distributions. We therefore conclude that the nontrivial behavior of the measured line shapes in the studied energy range can be understood in terms of strong coupled-channel effects with dynamically generated poles. The inclusion of bare compact states leads to a quantitative improvement of the fit quality but does not alter this conclusion.