On the later evolution of observationally selected protocluster candidates at $z\,{\gtrsim}\,5$

Abstract

Recent observations have revealed numerous protocluster candidates at $z\,{\gtrsim}\,5$, yet whether these systems will eventually evolve into today's galaxy clusters remains an open question. Using the FLAMINGO simulations -- resolving protocluster cores up to $z\,{\simeq}\,10$ -- we track the later evolution of observationally selected protocluster candidates, comparing three selection methods against observational samples. The observed number density falls between our mass-selected and abundance-matched samples, implying that current searches pick up both genuine cluster progenitors and significant interlopers that will not reach cluster masses by $z\,{=}\,0$. We find that candidates at $z\gtrsim5$ are heavily clustered, hosting 2$-$10 neighbors within 10\,cMpc. Consequently, a candidate with a neighbor at 5\,cMpc (10\,cMpc) faces a $\gtrsim50\%$ ($\gtrsim30\%$) probability of later merging into a larger system, mostly at $z\,{\lesssim}\,2$. The merger count converges beyond ${\sim}10$\,cMpc, pointing to a fundamental scale in structure formation. Observations show markedly weaker clustering than our simulations predict, suggesting clustering offers a currently overlooked diagnostic. Each candidate undergoes roughly 2$-$6 later major mergers, mostly with systems too small to be recognized as massive at the selection epoch. Hence, relying solely on high-$z$ mass and galaxy overdensity to forecast a candidate's fate is prone to severe scatter and systematic error. A robust identification of true cluster progenitors demands a total mass sum of galaxies down to the faintest levels within a 10\,cMpc radius. Upcoming surveys with both depth and area will be key to reliably linking high-$z$ protocluster candidates to their ultimate destiny.