Linear Ricci-Trace Deformations and Operational Equivalence in Rastall-Type Gravity

Abstract

We analyze a class of linear Ricci--trace deformations of Einstein's field equations in which the relative weight between the Ricci tensor and the scalar-curvature trace sector is modified while the metric remains the only gravitational field. The purpose of the analysis is structural rather than phenomenological: we classify the corresponding field-equation class, fix the parameter dictionaries commonly used in the Rastall-gravity literature, and identify which equivalence statements survive after Newtonian calibration. We show that two frequently used parametrizations, \[ (1-ε)R_{μν}-\frac12 g_{μν}R=κ_εT_{μν}, \qquad R_{μν}-\frac{1-λ}{2}g_{μν}R=κ_λT_{μν}, \] are algebraically isomorphic only if both the deformation parameter and the bare gravitational coupling are transformed simultaneously. This algebraic equivalence, however, is not automatically an operational equivalence. Once the same laboratory stress tensor and the same measured Newton constant are fixed, the parameter map is a passive reparametrization only at the Einstein point. We further identify the \(λ\)-representative with the standard Rastall equation, clarify the role of the conserved effective source, derive the corresponding FLRW perfect-fluid sector, and discuss degenerate cases including vacuum, trace-free matter, radiation, dust, and the singular traceless point. Finally, we distinguish the Ricci--trace class from Unimodular Gravity (UG): although both involve the trace sector, UG follows from a restricted variational principle and produces the cosmological constant as an integration constant, rather than from an algebraic Ricci--trace deformation. The result is a compact operational classification of Rastall-type Ricci--trace models.