Hunting for extreme high-energy-peaked BL Lacs: Rare to find and difficult to classify

Abstract

We explore the possible existence of a new population of BL Lacs, called ultra extreme high-energy-peaked BL Lacs (UEHBLs), whose synchrotron emission component peaks in the MeV band. In particular, we analysed Swift/XRT follow-up observations of a set of 10 hard X-ray sources from the Swift/BAT catalogues which were suggested to represent the first observational hints of this new blazar population on the basis of their spectral properties. We find that 6 of these candidate UEHBLs can be classified as line-emitting active galactic nuclei (AGNs), 4 of which are of type 2 and X-ray absorbed objects, while 2 are type 1 AGN and X-ray unabsorbed sources. In one more case, we find that the hard X-ray emission is probably the contribution of two line-emitting AGN, i.e. a Seyfert of type 1.9 and another of type 2. All these 7 classifications exclude the possibility that these hard X-ray sources are extreme BL Lacs. Of the remaining 3 UEHBL candidates, only 2 objects are found to have a spectral energy distribution (SED) compatible with those expected by MeV-peaked BL Lacs: however, in one of these 2 cases, an alternative Galactic association is also possible. The third source is instead likely associated with a more classical quasi-stellar object. Overall, we find that UEHBLs are extremely rare to find and probably very difficult to classify. Nevertheless, they represent a viable alternative classification for hard X-ray sources displaying no obvious or very weak counterparts.