Validating the ICCF-Cut Method with Simultaneous Photometric and Spectroscopic H$α$ Reverberation Mapping of NGC 4151 and UGC 3374

Abstract

Photometric reverberation mapping (RM) provides an efficient alternative to spectroscopic RM for probing the broad-line region (BLR) sizes in AGNs. In our previous work, we proposed the ICCF-Cut method, which extracts H$α$ emission-line variability from broadband photometric light curves and measures the lags to estimate the BLR sizes. To further assess the reliability of this method, we conduct simultaneous photometric and spectroscopic monitoring of two nearby Seyfert galaxies, NGC 4151 and UGC 3374, over multiple observing seasons using the Lijiang 2.4 m telescope. By directly comparing the photometric and spectroscopic RM results in each season, we find that the extracted H$α$ light curves using the ICCF-Cut method closely resemble those derived from spectroscopy. The photometric H$α$ lags are also generally consistent with the spectroscopic H$α$ lags within the uncertainties. For several seasons where the photometric H$α$ lags are slightly underestimated, we find that the discrepancy may be caused by residual He\,\textsc{i} contamination in the extracted H$α$ light curves. After correcting for this contamination, the photometric lag measurements become more consistent with the spectroscopic results. We further explore the performance of the ICCF-Cut method using the simulated light curves with different filter bandwidths. For our observational and simulated cases, the method can successfully recover the emission-line variability and lag measurements broadly consistent with the spectroscopic results. This provides further support for the applicability of the ICCF-Cut method in photometric RM.