Cluster vs Field: Clear Evidence for a Morphology-Density Relation in All Environments at $z\sim1.6$

Abstract

We explore the relationship between galaxy structure, stellar mass, and local galaxy density in three SpARCS clusters at $z\sim1.6$ and compare with field galaxies from the 3D-HST survey. Our cluster and field data include: 1) unprecedented multiband photometry, allowing for accurate stellar mass estimates; 2) extensive slit and grism spectroscopy targeting both star-forming and quiescent galaxies, allowing for high-accuracy local density measurements; and 3) deep imaging in F160W, allowing for accurate rest-frame optical morphologies. Using Sérsic index measured in rest-frame R-band, we classify galaxies as disk-like, bulge-like, and intermediate. Our sample includes 111 cluster galaxies and 458 field galaxies with reliable Sérsic measurements. We find that a morphology-density relation is already in-place in both cluster and field galaxies at $z\sim1.6$, such that as local density increases, the fraction of bulge-like galaxies increases and disk-like galaxies decreases. Both samples show similar positive trends between median Sérsic index and local density. Additionally, we find a general positive relationship between Sérsic index and stellar mass. The majority of galaxies remain disk-like until reaching stellar masses above $10^{10.25} M_\odot$ in the cluster or $10^{10.8} M_\odot$ in the field, however, we cannot conclude whether the differences in stellar mass trends are significant. Overall, our results show clear morphology-density and morphology-mass relations in place at $z\sim1.6$ and oppose the idea that cluster-specific processes are solely responsible the morphology-density relation. Our data further suggest that the morphology-density relation may be independent of global environment at this epoch.