Hubble as a Unique Discovery Engine of the Fate of Massive Stars and Black Hole Formation

Abstract

How stellar-mass black holes are formed is an open question in astrophysics, with very limited observational constraints. It is not known which types of stars are more likely to produce black holes, and whether the formation process is accompanied by strong or weak electromagnetic transients - or none at all - and this issue remains a critical missing piece in the puzzle of the fate of massive stars. Recent theoretical work predicts that many stellar-mass black holes form from hot, UV-luminous massive stars, including Wolf-Rayet-like progenitors, and searches focused primarily on luminous cool supergiants may therefore miss a substantial fraction of black-hole formation events. While the coming decade will bring major advances in time-domain astronomy through Rubin/LSST, Roman, JWST, and wide-field transient surveys, none of these combines UV sensitivity, sub-arcsecond imaging, and decade-long continuity. HST uniquely enables direct searches for disappearing hot massive stars associated with black-hole formation. We outline a roadmap for extending HST's role in this area into the 2030s through a dedicated, large program to re-image nearby galaxies in the UV and identify candidate disappearing stars and unusual low-luminosity transients identified by complementary surveys. Theoretical event rates imply that the nearby galaxy population accessible to HST should yield of order one detectable black-hole-forming disappearance event per year. Extending HST operations into the 2030s would therefore provide crucial insights into the unsolved problem of black hole formation.