Cosmic topology. Part IId. Eigenmodes and correlation matrices of lens spaces

Mikel Martin Barandiaran; Catherine Petretti; Stefano Anselmi; Deyan P. Mihaylov; Anna Negro; Glenn D. Starkman; Andrius Tamosiunas; Yashar Akrami; George Alestas; Javier Carrón Duque; Craig J. Copi; Fernando Cornet-Gomez; Linn Htat Lu; Andrew H. Jaffe; Arthur Kosowsky; José Javier Ortega Gómez; Ricardo G. Rodrigues; Amirhossein Samandar; Cynthia Trendafilova

doi:10.48550/arXiv.2610.12418

← Recent

AG-2026.10-1321·astro-ph.CO

Cosmic topology. Part IId. Eigenmodes and correlation matrices of lens spaces

Authors

Mikel Martin BarandiaranCOMPACT Collaboration
Catherine PetrettiCOMPACT Collaboration
Stefano AnselmiCOMPACT Collaboration
Deyan P. MihaylovCOMPACT Collaboration
Anna NegroCOMPACT Collaboration
Glenn D. StarkmanCOMPACT Collaboration
Andrius TamosiunasCOMPACT Collaboration
Yashar AkramiCOMPACT Collaboration
George AlestasCOMPACT Collaboration
Javier Carrón DuqueCOMPACT Collaboration
Craig J. CopiCOMPACT Collaboration
Fernando Cornet-GomezCOMPACT Collaboration
Linn Htat LuCOMPACT Collaboration

Andrew H. JaffeCOMPACT Collaboration

Arthur KosowskyCOMPACT Collaboration

José Javier Ortega GómezCOMPACT Collaboration

Ricardo G. RodriguesCOMPACT Collaboration

Amirhossein SamandarCOMPACT Collaboration

Cynthia TrendafilovaCOMPACT Collaboration

Abstract

The global topology of the Universe is a longstanding open question. In this work, we examine the statistical signatures of a positively curved universe with a Friedmann--Lemaitre--Robertson--Walker metric and the topology of a lens space $L(p,q)$. Since these manifolds are generally statistically anisotropic and inhomogeneous, their cosmic microwave background (CMB) covariance matrices contain non-zero off-diagonal entries that depend on observer location. We compute these full harmonic-space covariance matrices for scalar perturbations for arbitrary lens spaces and observer position. Using the Kullback--Leibler divergence, we assess the distinguishability of these spaces from a simply connected three-sphere with the same curvature. The results show that topological signatures can still be significant in a cosmic-variance-limited regime even when the length, $d_{\rm NC}$, of the shortest loop around the Universe through the observer exceeds the diameter, $d_{\rm LSS}$, of the last-scattering surface by up to $10\%$. This distinguishability depends on the curvature, the lens space and the observer position mainly through the ratio $d_{\rm NC}/d_{\rm LSS}$, which is set not only by the curvature radius but also by $p$, $q$ and the observer location. Therefore, for any value of the spatial curvature, however small, there are lens spaces and observer positions for which $0.985\,d_{\rm LSS}<d_{\rm NC}<1.1\,d_{\rm LSS}$. Such observers would find no matched circles in the CMB large enough to have been detected to date, yet the topology would remain potentially discoverable through its statistical signatures.

Submitted

8 October 20261 week ago

Version

v1

License

CC-BY-4.0

DOI

10.48550/arXiv.2610.12418

Cite this preprint

BibTeX RIS

Imports into BibLaTeX, Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote.

PDF

Open PDF

Opens in a new tab · v1.

Summary

We compute full harmonic-space CMB covariance matrices for lens space topologies and show that topological signatures remain statistically distinguishable from $S^3$ even when the shortest non-contractible loop exceeds the last-scattering surface diameter by up to 10%, depending on curvature, lens space parameters, and observer location.

For lens spaces $L(p,q)$, the off-diagonal covariance structure encodes position-dependent statistical anisotropy; distinguishability from $S^3$ via KL divergence depends primarily on the dimensionless ratio $d_{\rm NC}/d_{\rm LSS}$, which is jointly determined by curvature radius, topological parameters $(p,q)$, and observer position.
Topological signatures remain detectable in the cosmic-variance-limited regime even when the shortest non-contractible geodesic is 1–10% longer than the CMB horizon, ruling out matched-circle searches but preserving statistical detectability through covariance structure.
For arbitrarily small spatial curvature, there exist lens space configurations and observer positions satisfying $0.985\,d_{\rm LSS} < d_{\rm NC} < 1.1\,d_{\rm LSS}$, demonstrating that null matched-circle results do not exclude non-trivial topologies with detectable statistical signatures.

specialist · generated by claude-haiku-4-5

Chat with this PDF

Ask questions, probe assumptions, request a plain-English summary. Answers cite sections from the preprint itself.

Community

Questions and answers about this paper from other readers. No formal peer review — just a place to think out loud.