Sampling Bayesian probabilities given only sampled priors

Gary Bernstein; William Assignies Doumerg; Michael A. Troxel; Alex Alarcon; Alexandra Amon; Giulia Giannini; Boyan Yin; Sahar Allam; Felipe Andrade-Oliveira; David Brooks; Aurelio Carnero Rosell; Jorge Carretero; Luiz da Costa; Maria Elidaiana da Silva Pereira; Juan De Vicente; Spencer Everett; Josh Frieman; Juan Garcia-Bellido; Daniel Gruen; Samuel Hinton; Devon L. Hollowood; Klaus Honscheid; David James; Sujeong Lee; Jennifer Marshall; Juan Mena-Fernández; Ramon Miquel; Andrés Plazas Malagón; Eusebio Sanchez; David Sanchez Cid; Ignacio Sevilla; Tae-hyeon Shin; Mathew Smith; Eric Suchyta; Molly Swanson; Noah Weaverdyck; Jochen Weller; Philip Wiseman

doi:10.48550/arXiv.2506.00758

← Recent

AG-2025.06-001·astro-ph.IM·cross-listed: astro-ph.CO

Sampling Bayesian probabilities given only sampled priors

Authors

Gary Bernstein
William Assignies Doumerg
Michael A. Troxel
Alex Alarcon
Alexandra Amon
Giulia Giannini
Boyan Yin
Sahar Allam
Felipe Andrade-Oliveira
David Brooks
Aurelio Carnero Rosell
Jorge Carretero
Luiz da Costa
Maria Elidaiana da Silva Pereira
Juan De Vicente
Spencer Everett
Josh Frieman
Juan Garcia-Bellido
Daniel Gruen
Samuel Hinton
Devon L. Hollowood
Klaus Honscheid
David James

Sujeong Lee

Jennifer Marshall

Juan Mena-Fernández

Ramon Miquel

Andrés Plazas Malagón

Eusebio Sanchez

David Sanchez Cid

Ignacio Sevilla

Tae-hyeon Shin

Mathew Smith

Eric Suchyta

Molly Swanson

Noah Weaverdyck

Jochen Weller

Philip Wiseman

Abstract

A typical Bayesian inference on the values of some parameters of interest $q$ from some data $D$ involves running a Markov Chain (MC) to sample from the posterior $p(q,n | D) \propto \mathcal{L}(D | q,n) p(q) p(n),$ where $n$ are some nuisance parameters. In many cases, the nuisance parameters are high-dimensional, and their prior $p(n)$ is itself defined only by a set of samples that have been drawn from some other MC. Two problems arise: first, the MC for the posterior will typically require evaluation of $p(n)$ at arbitrary values of $n,$ \ie\ one needs to provide a density estimator over the full $n$ space from the provided samples. Second, the high dimensionality of $n$ hinders both the density estimation and the efficiency of the MC for the posterior. We describe a solution to this problem: a linear compression of the $n$ space into a much lower-dimensional space $u$ which projects away directions in $n$ space that cannot appreciably alter $\mathcal{L}.$ The algorithm for doing so is a slight modification to principal components analysis, and is less restrictive on $p(n)$ than other proposed solutions to this issue. We demonstrate this ``mode projection'' technique using the analysis of 2-point correlation functions of weak lensing fields and galaxy density in the \textit{Dark Energy Survey}, where $n$ is a binned representation of the redshift distribution $n(z)$ of the galaxies.

Submitted

1 June 202511 months ago

Version

v1

License

CC-BY-4.0

DOI

10.48550/arXiv.2506.00758

Cite this preprint

BibTeX RIS

Imports into BibLaTeX, Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote.

PDF

Open PDF

Opens in a new tab · v1.

Chat with this PDF

Ask questions, probe assumptions, request a plain-English summary. Answers cite sections from the preprint itself.

Community

Questions and answers about this paper from other readers. No formal peer review — just a place to think out loud.