Could black-hole photon rings show nonextensive correlations without any self-similar structure at all?

This is a sophisticated question that cuts across several subfields — nonextensive statistical mechanics, black hole photon dynamics, and fractal geometry. Let me work through what the archive shows.

The short answer: The archive doesn't directly address whether photon rings can exhibit nonextensive correlations without self-similar structure. But the papers do reveal an interesting tension that illuminates your question.

What we know about photon-ring structure

Photon rings *are* self-similar by default in standard Kerr black holes. When light grazes the unstable circular photon orbit, it can complete multiple windings before escaping, producing a nested hierarchy of subrings. This decomposition into "a self-similar hierarchy of subrings" [AG-2026.03-218] is a robust feature — the structure repeats at exponentially smaller scales, controlled by a Lyapunov exponent γ. The same paper shows this self-similarity persists in phase space and encodes fractal, chaotic dynamics [AG-2026.03-218].

Importantly, this self-similar nesting is *not* incidental: it emerges from the exponential sensitivity (the Lyapunov exponent) governing how nearby light rays diverge near the bound photon orbit. The ratio of successive ring intensities is tightly attached to this exponent [AG-2025.11-575].

Could you break that symmetry?

The archive hints at degrees of freedom. Beyond-Kerr geometries can modify photon-ring structure — for instance, non-singular black holes from Born-Infeld gravity show "relevant modifications to the typical photon ring" features [AG-2025.11-575], and parametrically deformed Kerr spacetimes (preserving integrable structure via Killing tensors) allow independent control of radial and polar photon dynamics [AG-2025.06-158]. So you *can* engineer deviations from the standard self-similar ladder.

However, whether those deviations could produce *nonextensive correlations* — in the technical sense of q-entropies or power-law correlation functions that violate additivity — is not explored in these papers. Nonextensivity typically arises in systems with long-range interactions, memory effects, or fractal phase spaces. Since the photon ring's self-similarity is intimately tied to the Lyapunov exponent and chaotic dynamics [AG-2026.03-218], suppressing self-similarity might actually *reduce* rather than enable nonextensive behavior.

The provided preprints don't directly address whether photon-ring correlations can be nonextensive without self-similarity.