How much would detection efficiency drop if angular distributions shift from proton to photon dumps?

Your question asks about detection efficiency changes when measurement systems shift from detecting protons to detecting photons. The preprints provided address related physics—photon and proton production in collisions, particle identification challenges, and angular distributions—but none directly analyzes how a detector's efficiency would *change* in such a transition.

That said, I can connect the relevant physics:

Angular distribution differences matter for detection. When proton-proton collisions produce secondary particles, the angular distribution of gamma rays differs from that of the initial protons [AG-2024.12-1415]. If a detector is optimized for collecting particles within a certain solid angle, switching from proton to photon collection would alter which fraction of events falls within that acceptance window. The paper provides the joint energy-angle distribution $d^2 N_γ/dE \, dΩ$ needed to calculate this loss.

Photon-like showers complicate background rejection. A practical concern: high-energy cosmic-ray proton showers can mimic photon showers when neutral pions carry most of the energy, degrading the ability to distinguish true photons [AG-2024.07-1464]. If you're comparing detection of real photons *versus* protons in an astrophysical context, photon detectors face contamination that proton detectors might avoid.

Cherenkov and scintillation responses differ. In liquid argon detectors, protons and photons produce light through different mechanisms—Cherenkov radiation versus scintillation—with distinct angular and spectral signatures [AG-2024.08-907]. The efficiency drop would depend on which light you're collecting and how well your optics match each particle type.

The preprints don't quantify efficiency loss for a specific detector geometry or experimental setup transitioning between proton and photon modes.