Could combining quasar data with future gravitational wave standard sirens further constrain dark energy properties?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Quasars and Standard Sirens: A Complementary Path to Dark Energy Yes — combining quasar data with gravitational wave standard sirens could meaningfully constrain dark energy, though the preprints focus primarily on sirens rather than explicit quasar synergy. Why Standard Sirens Matter for Dark Energy Gravitational wave standard sirens measure cosmic distances directly from the waveform itself (via luminosity distance), without relying on a cosmic distance ladder. This is powerful because it breaks degeneracies that plague other probes. When combined with redshift measurements—either from electromagnetic counterparts (bright sirens) or galaxy surveys—they anchor the expansion history of the universe [AG 2025.07 180, AG 2025.11 334]. The key innovation is that sirens probe the late universe (small redshifts, recent cosmic times) independently of the cosmic microwave background. This matters because there is currently tension between early universe measurements (from CMB) and late universe measurements of the Hubble constant [AG 2025.11 334]. A fully late universe dataset—sirens + galaxy surveys + supernovae—sidesteps this tension [AG 2025.11 334]. Combining with Other Datasets The preprints show that standard sirens gain power when pooled with other distance indicators. For instance, using 47 gravitational wave events from existing catalogs alongside baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) data from galaxy surveys and Type Ia supernovae, researchers obtained the Hubble constant and dark energy equation of state parameters without reference to the CMB [AG 2025.11 334]. Adding DESI BAO measurements to future gravitational wave data will "significantly reduce uncertainties in cosmological parameters" [AG 2025.04 103]. This logic extends naturally to quasars: they can serve as standardizable distance indicators if their intrinsic brightness can be calibrated reliably. Combined with sirens' direct distance measurements, the two probes would diversify systematics (different physical mechanisms, different redshift ranges), improving robustness. Future Precision Next generation detectors—the Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer—will observe hundreds of binary neutron star mergers with electromagnetic counterparts over five years [AG 2025.07 180]. Multi band observations (combining different gravitational wave frequencies) further sharpen sky localization, improving Hubble constant precision by 52–85% [AG 2024.04 514]. These sensitivities will allow joint fits to parameterized dark energy models [AG 2025.07 180] and dynamical dark energy scenarios [AG 2025.04 103]. The provided preprints do not explicitly analyze quasar+siren combinations, focusing instead on sirens with BAO and supernovae.