Can MOND and Weyl coupling simultaneously explain both rotation curves and the cosmic microwave background?

This is an excellent question about whether any single theory can simultaneously handle two of the most challenging observational targets in cosmology: galactic dynamics and the CMB.

The short answer from the archive: yes, at least in principle, but with significant caveats.

The Promise: Unified Models

The strongest case comes from nonlocal gravity. [AG-2025.12-255] reports a single nonlocal gravity model that "interpolates between" MOND-like behavior in bound systems and full cosmological predictions—explicitly including the CMB, baryon acoustic oscillations, and structure formation. This is significant because most MOND variants struggle at cosmological scales; they explain galaxy rotation curves beautifully but break down when you try to match precision CMB data.

A relativistic MOND framework [AG-2026.01-159] also attempts a unified approach by embedding MOND into a gauge theory motivated by $E_6 \times E_6$ symmetry. Here, General Relativity emerges exactly at high acceleration (recovering standard cosmology), while the low-acceleration MOND regime applies at galactic scales. The theory does not require new scalar fields beyond those in the gauge sector, which is technically cleaner than many ad-hoc modifications.

Weyl Coupling: A Separate Path

Weyl tensor coupling [AG-2026.04-061] successfully reproduces galactic rotation curves without dark matter by modifying the Einstein-Hilbert action. However, the archive does not contain evidence that this approach has been tested against CMB data. This is a crucial gap—a theory can fit rotation curves perfectly but still predict the wrong primordial perturbations and temperature power spectrum.

The Tension Problem

A sobering reality check: [AG-2024.01-118] documents an 8.7σ tension between the constraints MOND must satisfy to fit galactic rotation curves and those imposed by Solar System tests (the quadrupole moment). This tension suggests that no simple MOND variant may be able to satisfy *all* precision tests simultaneously—let alone also match the CMB.

Where the Archive Stops

The provided preprints do not directly test whether Weyl coupling can reproduce CMB anisotropies, nor do they compare Weyl coupling to the nonlocal or relativistic MOND frameworks on cosmological scales. A complete answer would require papers explicitly computing CMB power spectra in these theories.