Do second-order transitions produce detectable gravitational waves, or is the domain-wall signal too weak for LIGO?

# Second-order transitions and domain-wall gravitational waves

The short answer: yes, domain walls from second-order transitions can produce detectable gravitational waves, but the signal is considerably weaker than from first-order transitions — and whether LIGO can see it depends on the specific model and parameters.

The physics of second-order domain walls

In a second-order phase transition, the order parameter (a quantum field) changes smoothly rather than jumping discontinuously. This means there's no violent bubble collision or turbulent fluid motion — the main gravitational-wave factories of first-order transitions. Instead, the primary GW source becomes the annihilation of domain walls [AG-2026.03-1510].

Domain walls are topological defects — thin, extended interfaces where the order parameter takes opposite values on either side, like a cosmic membrane. They're created copiously in second-order transitions and carry energy. Over time, they collide and annihilate, releasing energy as gravitational waves.

The detection challenge

The signal is much quieter than first-order physics for a simple reason: there's less bulk energy being violently disturbed. A first-order transition creates both shock waves and domain walls [AG-2026.03-1510], yielding a "twin-peaked" gravitational-wave spectrum. A second-order transition loses the shocks entirely, leaving only the gentler domain-wall contribution.

However, the archive doesn't directly quantify how much weaker the domain-wall signal is, nor does it provide a detailed LIGO sensitivity comparison for second-order scenarios. The papers focus mainly on first-order transitions and topological defects, which are generally louder.

Future prospects

Next-generation detectors like Einstein Telescope will have much better reach into the early universe's phase transitions [AG-2024.06-069], suggesting that second-order signals — while marginal for current LIGO — may be resolvable in the coming decade at higher sensitivities.

---

The provided preprints don't give a quantitative estimate of domain-wall signal strength in second-order transitions or explicit LIGO detectability thresholds for that scenario.