What physical mechanism causes the apparent horizon to stall or bounce in charged black hole collapse?

The Mechanism Behind Apparent Horizon Stalling and Bouncing

The apparent horizon—the outermost boundary of the trapped region inside a collapsing object—can stall (pause temporarily) or reverse direction entirely in charged black hole collapse. This happens because of electrostatic repulsion between the collapsing charged matter and the charged black hole core.

### How Charge Creates the Bounce

In ordinary uncharged (Schwarzschild) collapse, gravity pulls everything inward relentlessly. But when both the infalling matter and the black hole carry electric charge of the same sign, they repel each other. If the charge density is high enough relative to the mass, this repulsive force can overwhelm gravity at some radius, forcing the surface to stop collapsing and reverse outward [AG-2026.02-106].

Think of it as trying to push two magnets together with the same poles facing: gravity plays the role of your hand pushing inward, while the electromagnetic force pushes back outward. At some point, if the magnets are strong enough, they reverse direction.

### The Apparent-Horizon Turning Point

In charged black holes with two horizons (inner and outer, as in Reissner-Nordström spacetimes), the apparent horizon can develop a "left vertex"—a temporary minimum in its radius during collapse [AG-2026.02-106]. This is the stalling phenomenon: the horizon radius momentarily stops shrinking before continuing inward.

A crucial constraint for this to be physically consistent is that the apparent-horizon turning point must occur after the collapsing surface crosses the inner horizon [AG-2026.02-106]. This ensures the trapped region remains well-defined.

### A Microscopic Picture: Charged Null Dust

At the most extreme level, charged particles falling in can literally bounce off the electromagnetic barrier. In models where infalling matter consists of massless charged particles (null dust), the electrostatic repulsion can be so violent that particles instantaneously reverse direction along a timelike "bounce hypersurface" [AG-2026.02-353]. The spacetime metric remains regular across this bounce—no singularity is created—and the reversed particles can be consistently matched to the Reissner-Nordström exterior [AG-2026.02-353].

### Classification of Collapse Outcomes

Oppenheimer-Snyder collapse in charged spacetimes naturally sorts into three categories [AG-2026.02-106]:

1. Singular: collapse reaches the center in finite time (low charge).

2. Bouncing: the surface stops and reverses at a finite radius (moderate-to-high charge).

3. Soft-landing: the surface asymptotically approaches the center (e.g., in regular black holes with de Sitter cores, which have no bounce).

### Why This Matters

The bounce mechanism shows that electric charge can prevent singularity formation—at least for the collapsing surface itself. However, this doesn't mean the interior is benign: near-extremal (nearly uncharged-to-maximally-charged) transitions may develop large scalar curvatures visible to distant observers, and there are instabilities at the inner horizons of charged black holes [AG-2026.02-242]. So while the bounce delays or avoids the classical singularity, quantum or nonlinear effects near the horizon remain a frontier question.