How would galaxy cluster dynamics differ if MOND operated at cosmic expansion scales instead?

This is a fascinating counterfactual, but the archive doesn't directly address it. Let me work through what we know about MOND at different scales to sketch an answer.

The cluster problem today

First, the baseline: MOND already *fails* at galaxy cluster scales in our universe. The theory predicts rotation curves and gravitational dynamics beautifully for individual galaxies [AG-2025.05-332], but when applied to clusters, it leaves behind a substantial residual missing-mass problem—roughly a factor of 10 discrepancy in the inner regions [AG-2024.10-060]. This happens because MOND's modification to gravity (below an acceleration threshold $a_0 \approx 10^{-10}$ m/s²) is *too weak* to account for the dynamical support clusters need [AG-2026.02-201].

Scaling the modification to cosmic expansion

Your question asks: what if MOND's low-acceleration regime *shifted* to operate at cosmic expansion scales (roughly $H_0 \sim 10^{-18}$ m/s², the acceleration scale of the expanding universe) instead of at galactic scales?

The immediate consequence: the acceleration threshold would drop by roughly 8 orders of magnitude. This means:

1. Galaxy clusters would enter the MOND regime much more easily. Currently, cluster-scale accelerations (~10⁻¹² m/s²) sit awkwardly *between* the Newtonian regime and MOND's low-acceleration sweet spot. Pushing $a_0$ down to cosmic scales would pull clusters squarely into MOND's modified dynamics, where the effective gravitational acceleration scales as $\sqrt{a_{\text{Newtonian}} \cdot a_0}$ [AG-2025.01-283]. This would *amplify* gravity in clusters relative to today's MOND predictions.

2. Galaxy rotation curves would move toward the Newtonian regime. Galactic accelerations (~10⁻¹¹ m/s² at large radii) would now sit well above the new threshold, reducing MOND's correction. The flat rotation curves MOND currently explains [AG-2025.01-283] would become less flat, requiring more dark matter to match observations.

3. Cosmic expansion itself would be modified. The Friedmann equations governing the universe's acceleration would enter MOND's domain, potentially offering a modified-gravity explanation for cosmic acceleration without dark energy [AG-2025.02-355]. However, this is speculative; the archive doesn't detail how a shifted $a_0$ would affect cosmology.

The deeper tension

Importantly, MOND already faces a severe internal tension: the Solar System's gravitational field places tight constraints on how sharply the modification can transition between regimes, and these constraints *contradict* what galaxies require [AG-2024.01-118]. Shifting $a_0$ to cosmic scales would only deepen this problem—the Solar System's quadrupole would demand an even sharper transition, while galaxies would demand something gentler.

Bottom line: The archive doesn't contain calculations for this scenario, so this remains educated extrapolation rather than tested prediction.