Can two-loop effects flip the sign of Wilson coefficients for lepton-number-violating processes?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Yes, two loop effects can flip the sign of Wilson coefficients for lepton number violating processes, though this is a subtle phenomenon that depends on the specific operators involved. The mechanism In effective field theory descriptions of lepton number violation, Wilson coefficients evolve with energy scale through renormalization group equations (RGEs). At one loop, these coefficients mix according to a specific pattern—some operators generate others, some don't, and the mixing matrix has certain zeroes. Two loop contributions alter this structure fundamentally. The clearest example comes from the Weinberg operator, the dimension 5 lepton number violating operator responsible for neutrino masses [AG 2024.11 1192]. At two loops, "new diagrams" appear that weren't present at one loop, and these can actually increase the "rank" of the mixing matrix—meaning new operator mixing channels open up that were forbidden at lower order. Since the RGE evolution matrix changes, the relative signs and magnitudes of coefficients along a given renormalization trajectory can reverse [AG 2024.11 1192]. More broadly, the two loop SMEFT RGEs show that two loop contributions "break zeroes present at one loop order" [AG 2026.04 1240]. When a zero in the mixing matrix disappears, that previously decoupled channel becomes active. Depending on the sign structure of the new two loop contributions versus the surviving one loop terms, this can cause the net coefficient for a given process to flip sign as you evolve from one energy scale to another. Why this matters Sign flips in Wilson coefficients are phenomenologically important because experiments measure rates , which depend on the squared coefficients—but theoretical predictions often depend on interference between different operator contributions. If two contributions nearly cancel at one loop but the sign flips at two loops, the cancellation is destroyed, potentially making a rare process observable when one loop predictions suggested it was suppressed [AG 2025.03 1775]. For concrete applications: neutrinoless double beta decay ($0νββ$) receives contributions from multiple dimension 5 and dimension 7 lepton number violating operators, and loop level mixing between them can "remarkably improve" or worsen bounds on new physics scales [AG 2025.03 1775]. The interplay between one loop dimension 5 and tree level dimension 7 contributions is delicate, and including two loop effects reshuffles these balances.