Could a homogeneous nonreciprocal material generate force through thermal nonequilibrium alone at second order?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Thermal Nonequilibrium Force in Homogeneous Materials at Second Order No—a homogeneous nonreciprocal material cannot generate force through thermal nonequilibrium alone at second order. The key constraint is inhomogeneity . What the archive shows The foundational result here is systematic: forces and torques arise at different orders depending on material properties [AG 2024.11 890]: First order (in electric susceptibility expansion): Torque can arise, but only in nonreciprocal materials. No force at all. Second order : Both forces and torques can arise—but crucially, only if the body is inhomogeneous [AG 2024.11 890], [AG 2024.05 941]. Why inhomogeneity matters The mechanism is radiation asymmetry. A body out of thermal equilibrium with the vacuum emits an asymmetric radiation pattern [AG 2024.11 890]. At second order, an ordinary (reciprocal) material can exploit this asymmetry—but only if different regions of the body have different susceptibilities. Inhomogeneity breaks the symmetry that would otherwise cancel the net force. The archive provides concrete second order examples: a needle made of two different materials, hemispheres of different substances, and slabs with different faces [AG 2024.05 941]. All are inhomogeneous. The homogeneous case Homogeneous nonreciprocal materials (requiring external fields like magnets [AG 2024.05 941]) do generate torque at first order, but they produce no self propulsive force even at second order—the material's uniformity prevents the directional asymmetry needed for propulsion [AG 2024.05 941]. In higher orders, inhomogeneity "may be removed" [AG 2024.11 890], suggesting force generation becomes possible for homogeneous materials only at third order and beyond—well beyond second order.