Could the difference stem from where particles interact relative to their decay length in the nucleus?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Your question hinges on a genuinely interesting idea: could where in the nucleus a decay product forms or interacts affect the measured decay rate? The preprints provided touch on related territory but don't directly address decay length spatial dependence. Let me explain what's closest: Nuclear effects on decay products: When a particle decays inside nuclear matter, the daughter particles don't simply leave unimpeded [AG 2025.02 1300]. The analysis of proton decay ($p ightarrow \pi^+ + \bar{
u}$ and $p ightarrow K^+ + \bar{
u}$) shows that final state interactions—where the pion or kaon collides with other nucleons before escaping—depend on the mean free path of those particles in the medium. A decay happening near the nuclear surface gives daughters more direct access to escape; one deep inside faces more scattering. This would modulate observed decay signatures, though it doesn't directly change the intrinsic decay lifetime. Finite volume and confinement effects: There's a tantalizing hint in a different direction [AG 2025.04 1188]. When particles are confined to finite volumes (like neutrons in a bottle or nucleons in a nucleus), their momentum spectra become discrete rather than continuous. The paper proposes this could actually affect decay probabilities themselves, using neutron decay as a test case. If true, a particle's confinement length scale could influence its decay rate—not just the observable distribution of products. The neutron lifetime puzzle as a precedent: Interestingly, the neutron lifetime discrepancy between beam and bottle experiments [AG 2024.03 939] has been attributed to excited states decoupling at different times, which is a temporal rather than spatial effect—but it shows that subtle environmental factors can shift decay measurements significantly. None of these papers squarely examines whether spatial position within a nucleus at the moment of decay affects the lifetime itself, which is what your question seems to ask.