Could modified gravity alternatives explain flat rotation curves without introducing dark matter entirely?

Yes, several modified gravity approaches have been proposed to explain flat rotation curves without invoking dark matter particles, though the archive reveals significant challenges to each.

Modified Theories with Mixed Results

Weyl-coupled gravity shows the most concrete promise. By coupling the Weyl tensor (a component of spacetime curvature encoding tidal forces) to matter, researchers found that a single coupling constant fit both the Milky Way and M31 when modeled with realistic, radially-varying density profiles [AG-2026.04-061]. This is encouraging because it suggests a universal prescription rather than one tweaked per galaxy.

Conformal gravity — which adds a linear potential term beyond Newton's inverse-square law — has been tested successfully against spiral galaxy rotation curves [AG-2025.06-260] and appears consistent with Type Ia supernovae observations. The key insight is that this extra potential naturally produces the constant velocity at large radii that dark matter was invoked to explain.

Chameleon gravity offers an intriguing middle ground: it introduces a scalar field (related to modified gravity) that behaves like dark matter on galactic scales, producing flat rotation curves without exotic particles [AG-2025.07-375]. The mass of this field grows linearly with radius, yielding constant tangential speed — matching observations without a separate dark matter halo.

Hyperconical geometry and MOND-like models also show promise, with the former fitting 123 galaxy rotation curves and the latter constraining the acceleration scale where Newton's law breaks down to ~10^−10 m/s² [AG-2024.10-139], [AG-2025.02-355].

The Catch: General Relativity Itself Doesn't Help Much

The critical limitation: standard General Relativity's weak-field limit produces only ~10^−6 corrections to Newtonian predictions for realistic baryonic disks—far too small to flatten rotation curves [AG-2024.11-099]. This means you cannot rescue dark matter by appealing to relativistic effects in Einstein's original theory; you must genuinely *modify* gravity's structure.

An alternative geometric idea—a vortex-like mass distribution threading the galaxy's center—has been explored but remains speculative [AG-2024.08-296].

The Unresolved Question

Whether any single modified theory works universally across *all* scales (galaxies, clusters, cosmic expansion) remains open [AG-2024.10-097]. MOND variants, for instance, struggle with this universality—different regimes seem to need different prescriptions.

In short: yes, modified gravity *can* explain flat curves without dark matter, but no consensus candidate has yet displaced the dark matter picture across all observations.