How does imposing irrotationality affect the range of achievable bubble velocities compared to unconstrained solutions?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Irrotationality and Bubble Wall Velocities Your question asks about a fluid dynamics constraint—irrotationality (zero vorticity)—and how it bounds achievable bubble velocities. The provided preprints focus on vacuum and phase transition bubbles in cosmology and condensed matter, where irrotationality is not imposed as a foundational assumption. Let me explain what they do reveal about velocity limits. What the archive shows instead The preprints explore velocity ranges through physical constraints rather than mathematical assumptions like irrotationality: Hydrodynamic obstruction is the key concept. When a bubble wall expands in a hot plasma (or superfluid), the surrounding fluid resists the wall's motion. The friction is not monotonic in velocity; instead, there exists a maximum friction force before the wall reaches the speed of light [AG 2024.01 626]. This "hydrodynamic obstruction" creates an effective ceiling on wall velocity, independent of whether vorticity is allowed. In local thermal equilibrium, bubble walls reach terminal velocities determined by entropy conservation [AG 2024.11 909], typically remaining subsonic due to dissipation [AG 2026.04 860]. However, early stage runaway dynamics can exceed these predictions, because the heated fluid shell that would normally provide backreaction hasn't yet formed [AG 2024.02 1161]. This runaway is dynamical, not forbidden by any constraint. Bounds from first principles : A model independent approach derives upper and lower velocity bounds—the local thermal equilibrium and ballistic limits—without invoking collision terms [AG 2024.11 1355]. The ballistic (non equilibrium) case yields slightly slower walls than the thermal case, suggesting that velocity decreases when particles are far from equilibrium [AG 2024.11 909]. The irrotationality gap None of these studies impose irrotationality (∇ × v = 0) as a constraint. In fact, rotating fluid elements and vortex formation are observed in multi bubble collisions [AG 2026.04 860], and vortex tangles sustain turbulent flow in superfluids [AG 2024.02 1690]. An irrotational restriction would eliminate these regimes entirely—a much stronger constraint than what these papers explore. This archive does not directly compare velocity ranges under irrotational vs. unconstrained flow.