How would a fifth force coupling only to ordinary matter show up differently in these same redshift-velocity dispersion measurements?

# A Fifth Force Coupling Only to Ordinary Matter: A Distinctive Signature

The key insight is that a fifth force selective to ordinary matter would leave a different fingerprint than one acting on dark matter—it would decouple the dynamics of the two components in a measurable way.

The Standard Degeneracy Problem

Normally, distinguishing between modified gravity and a fifth force is notoriously difficult. Both can produce the same patterns in large-scale structure growth and lensing [AG-2024.04-266]. But this degeneracy breaks when you add another constraint.

How Ordinary-Matter-Only Coupling Shows Up

If a fifth force coupled *only* to ordinary matter (baryons and radiation), it would alter how ordinary matter accelerates in gravitational potential wells—but leave dark matter unaffected. In redshift-velocity dispersion measurements in galaxy clusters, this would create a mismatch:

• Ordinary matter would experience an extra acceleration from the fifth force, shifting its velocity profile.
• Dark matter would fall normally under gravity alone.
• The two populations would have different velocity dispersions than predicted by standard gravity—a smoking-gun signature.

More precisely, the equivalence principle—the statement that all matter falls the same way through gravity—would be *selectively violated* [AG-2026.01-524]. When you compare the gravitational redshift signal (which probes the depth of the potential well) against the velocity dispersions (which depend on how matter actually moves), an ordinary-matter-only fifth force would create a detectable tension between these two measurements [AG-2026.01-524, AG-2025.02-218].

Current Constraints

Current cluster data already constrain a positive fifth force to less than 7% of gravitational strength [AG-2025.02-218]. A selective coupling to ordinary matter would likely be even more tightly constrained, because you'd need it strong enough to show up in the velocity data but weak enough not to wreck predictions for baryon acoustic oscillations or the cosmic microwave background.

The key advantage: ordinary matter leaves more direct observational traces (we see galaxies, gas, stars) than dark matter, so a fifth force affecting only baryons would be harder to hide.

---

The preprints focus mainly on degenerate dark-matter fifth forces or screened modifications of gravity; they don't directly address selective ordinary-matter coupling, so this answer extrapolates from the equivalence-principle tests they describe.