Why does a heavier nucleus produce more muons than a lighter one in the same energy range?

Your question touches on a real puzzle in cosmic-ray physics, but the preprints provided address it only indirectly.

The core issue is this: when a high-energy cosmic ray smashes into the atmosphere, it creates a shower of secondary particles, including muons. Experiments consistently observe *more* muons from heavy nuclei (like iron) than predictions suggest [AG-2024.04-1007, AG-2025.08-1155]. The "muon puzzle" refers to this persistent discrepancy between data and simulations.

Why might heavier nuclei produce more muons? The most straightforward explanation involves hadron production—the process by which the initial collision fragments into pions and other mesons that later decay into muons. Different nuclei have different internal structures (more nucleons, different binding energy distributions), which can alter how particles are produced in the collision. When a cosmic ray hits a heavier nucleus, the collision geometry and energy-sharing among secondary particles may favor pathways that produce more pions, and thus more muons downstream [AG-2024.04-1007].

However, the archives don't contain a paper that directly compares muon yields from light vs. heavy nuclei at fixed incident energy, or that explains the *mechanism* behind the asymmetry. The papers here focus on modeling uncertainties in extensive air shower simulations and the broader muon excess puzzle, not on nucleus-mass-dependent muon production rates in a controlled setting.