What happens to detection efficiency if you use NA62's geometry for a LUXE-style photon search?

This is a great cross-experiment geometry question—it touches on a real design trade-off in beam-dump physics.

The short answer: detection efficiency would likely suffer, because NA62's geometry is optimized for a different physics signature than LUXE's photon search.

Here's why. LUXE is designed primarily to study strong-field QED but can search for new spin-0 particles produced when a high-intensity photon beam hits a target [AG-2025.07-1520]. The experiment's detector geometry is laid out to capture particles emerging from that photon-dump interaction, with particular sensitivity to the 10–350 MeV mass and 10⁻⁶–10⁻³ GeV⁻¹ coupling ranges [AG-2025.07-1520].

NA62, by contrast, is a fixed-target facility that has been repurposed for dark-sector searches using a proton beam dump [AG-2026.01-1312, AG-2025.02-1162]. The key insight from NO LESS is that "geometric setup is particularly relevant for the specific new-physics scenario under study, since different production mechanisms can generate different angular distributions of new particles" [AG-2026.01-1312].

A proton beam dump produces new particles with a different angular spread and momentum distribution than a photon beam dump does. If you kept NA62's detector geometry but fed it LUXE's photon beam, you'd be asking the detector to catch particles with kinematic distributions it was never designed for. You might miss particles going in directions where NA62 has sparse instrumentation, or waste detector coverage on regions where photon-dump particles are unlikely to appear.

The NO LESS paper actually explores exactly this kind of optimization: they show that "even the most minimalistic reconfiguration of the existing NA62 experiment's detectors can already provide very competitive sensitivity" [AG-2026.01-1312] for beam-dump work—implying that *without* reconfiguration, you leave efficiency on the table.

The preprints don't directly compare detection efficiency numbers for this specific LUXE-on-NA62 geometry swap, so I can't give you a quantitative estimate.