How do intrinsic jet delays differ between long and short GRBs mechanistically?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Your question asks about intrinsic jet delays —the time differences at which high energy photons are emitted from the jet itself, before propagating to Earth—and how these differ mechanistically between long and short GRBs. Unfortunately, the preprints provided don't directly address intrinsic emission time delays as a distinguishing feature between long and short GRBs. The closest relevant work is [AG 2024.08 425], which studies energy dependent intrinsic time delays in GRBs using Fermi data and tests whether delays arise from Lorentz invariance violation or from source intrinsic effects (like energy correlated emission times). However, this paper treats both long and short GRBs together for the purpose of testing fundamental physics, and doesn't compare the mechanisms of delay between the two classes. The archive does contain material on what produces long versus short GRBs: [AG 2024.12 372] argues that long and short GRBs may share a common evolutionary channel (the binary driven hypernova model), challenging the traditional picture that long GRBs come from massive star collapse and short GRBs from compact object mergers. [AG 2025.01 476], [AG 2025.01 463], [AG 2025.05 599] focus on jet propagation through post merger environments in short GRBs, showing how injection parameters (luminosity, magnetization, launch timing) shape jet evolution. [AG 2026.01 262] explores jets from proto magnetars, which could power either long or short bursts depending on progenitor. None of these directly compares the intrinsic time delay mechanisms between the two classes.