How does the Unruh temperature scale compare to actual thermal effects in galactic rotation curves?

# Unruh Temperature and Galaxy Rotation Curves: Connecting Two Scales

The Unruh temperature and actual thermal effects in galactic rotation curves operate at wildly different physical scales and through fundamentally different mechanisms, though one recent proposal attempts to bridge them.

The Unruh Temperature Scale

The Unruh effect predicts that an accelerating observer perceives the quantum vacuum as a thermal bath [AG-2024.10-003]. For an observer undergoing constant linear acceleration *a*, the effective temperature is *T* = ℏ*a*/(2π*c*k_B) — roughly 10^−21 K per meter per second squared of acceleration. This is a purely kinematic effect in quantum field theory: the observer's acceleration warps their perception of quantum fluctuations into a heat-like spectrum [AG-2025.11-343]. The effect is unimaginably small in most settings; even electrons in intense laser-plasma accelerators would measure temperatures only around 10^10 K if the Unruh effect were observable [AG-2024.10-440].

Thermal Effects in Galaxy Rotation

Real galaxies are not in thermal equilibrium—they are complex many-body systems with structure, dynamics, and irreversible processes. The standard explanation for flat rotation curves invokes dark matter, but a 2024 proposal reframes the problem using "thermal gravity" [AG-2024.03-289]. This theory posits that spatial and temporal variations in temperature can couple to spacetime curvature, creating an effective gravitational contribution. Rather than detecting the Unruh effect directly, galaxies would exhibit thermal gravity effects arising from actual thermodynamic gradients in their stellar populations and gas—temperatures ranging from thousands to millions of Kelvin. The theory introduces a "degree of thermalization" parameter to account for the fact that galaxies are only partially thermalized, and this extended framework (called "many-body gravity") reportedly explains the rotation curves of the Milky Way and Andromeda to reasonable accuracy [AG-2024.03-289].

The Connection

These are not competing mechanisms but vastly different regimes. The Unruh temperature is a quantum vacuum effect scaled to accelerations; thermal gravity in galaxies is a classical-to-semiclassical effect tied to *actual* temperature distributions in matter and spacetime. The Unruh effect is so small that detecting it requires specially designed quantum detectors [AG-2024.06-745]; galactic thermal effects, if real, would be macroscopic consequences of thermodynamic structure in the cosmos.

In short: the Unruh temperature is a theoretical prediction for what an accelerating quantum observer would feel in the vacuum, while galactic rotation curves may reflect how real, astrophysical temperatures couple to gravity—two different beasts separated by roughly 30 orders of magnitude in temperature and many in physical context.