Does the type of collapsing matter fundamentally alter how quickly the apparent horizon can form relative to singularity formation?

# Does the Type of Collapsing Matter Affect Horizon Formation Speed Relative to Singularity?

Yes, the type of matter fundamentally changes the relative timing of horizon and singularity formation.

The key finding is that the dynamics of the apparent horizon—which depends on the matter's properties—determines whether a singularity becomes visible or gets hidden [AG-2025.08-394]. In other words, different matter types form apparent horizons at different rates during collapse, and this directly governs singularity visibility. The precise conditions depend on "the relative timing of formation of trapped surfaces and the singularity," characterized through outgoing null geodesic families from the central singularity [AG-2025.08-394].

Several concrete examples show this effect:

Dust collapse (the simplest case, where pressure is zero) exhibits a covered singularity in the region far from the center [AG-2026.03-477], though quantum or shell-crossing effects may alter this near the singularity. When dust collapse is studied in quantum gravity frameworks, it still produces horizons with Reissner-Nordström-like causal structures, but nonhomogeneous dust can develop shell-crossing singularities that block the spacetime geometry in ways homogeneous collapse does not [AG-2024.10-565].

Charged and anisotropic matter change the story more dramatically. Generalizations including electric charge (Reissner-Nordström), cosmological constants, and anisotropic pressure show that "these factors significantly influence the collapse process" [AG-2025.06-253]. Anisotropic collapse exhibits a striking double apparent-horizon phase inside the matter during the collapse, with the event horizon stabilizing only at the Schwarzschild radius [AG-2025.12-429]—a feature absent in isotropic models.

Scalar fields can even produce naked singularities under certain conditions, violating cosmic censorship [AG-2025.09-082], whereas dust does not. This means scalar-field collapse can form singularities *faster* than horizons, whereas dust collapse typically forms horizons first.

The bottom line: matter composition (dust vs. charged vs. anisotropic vs. scalar field) is not a decoration on collapse—it sets the *causal order* between horizon and singularity formation, determining whether observers outside can ever see the singularity.