How would graviton speed variations manifest differently than redshift drift in a single binary merger event?

This is a sharp technical question that goes to heart of how gravitational wave observations can distinguish between *propagation effects* and *source physics*.

The Core Distinction

Redshift drift and graviton speed variations are fundamentally different phenomena that would leave distinct signatures in a single merger event [AG-2025.05-280]:

Redshift drift is a time-dependent *cosmological* effect. As gravitational waves propagate through the expanding universe, the redshift changes gradually during the observation window. This manifests as a slow, systematic frequency decrease in the waveform phase that depends on the expansion history of the universe—not on the graviton's intrinsic propagation speed. The key insight is that redshift drift affects the *dimensionless* source parameters (like the frequencies of different oscillation modes in a postmerger signal) differently than it affects the overall "redshifted mass" [AG-2025.05-280]. This allows observers to break the usual degeneracy between source distance and intrinsic mass.

Graviton speed variations, by contrast, are *propagation* deviations from general relativity. If gravitons travel at a speed $c_{\rm gw} \neq c$, or if they experience vacuum dispersion (where different frequencies propagate at slightly different speeds), those differences accumulate continuously across the distance traveled [AG-2025.11-120]. This produces a cumulative phase shift in the entire waveform that grows monotonically with distance, independent of cosmic expansion.

How They Differ Observationally

In a binary merger event, you could distinguish them because:

1. Timescale dependence: Redshift drift modulates the waveform *during* the observation window in a way tied to the source's redshift and the cosmic expansion rate [AG-2025.05-280]. Graviton speed variation produces a fixed phase lag proportional to distance that doesn't change *within* a single event.

2. Frequency structure: Redshift drift leaves subtle imprints on the *ratios* of post-merger frequencies and their quality factors, which are dimensionless and therefore encode information about redshift itself [AG-2025.05-280]. Graviton speed variation (especially with dispersion) would instead create frequency-dependent phase shifts—higher frequencies and lower frequencies would arrive at slightly different times [AG-2025.11-120].

3. Multi-messenger anchors: If you observe both gravitational waves and electromagnetic counterparts (as in binary neutron star mergers), the time delay between their arrivals directly constrains $c_{\rm gw}$ versus $c$ [AG-2024.08-011], [AG-2024.08-065]. Redshift drift doesn't create a GW–EM speed difference; it affects both equally.

The practical upshot: a single merger's waveform carries imprints of redshift drift in its internal structure (post-merger oscillations), while graviton speed variations show up as external, distance-dependent phase lags that are best constrained by comparing populations of events or using multi-messenger observations [AG-2024.08-011], [AG-2025.11-120].