Do existing silicon detector ionization signatures rule out fractional charge particles outright?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Silicon Detectors and Fractional Charge Searches No — existing silicon detector signatures do not rule out fractional charge particles outright. In fact, the detectors are actively being refined to search for them. The key insight is that fractionally charged particles leave distinctive ionization signatures that differ from standard particles, and this difference is a feature , not a bug. What silicon detectors can see When a fractionally charged particle (say, charge e /3) passes through silicon, it ionizes fewer electrons than a standard relativistic particle would, simply because ionization scales with charge [AG 2024.02 1255]. Modern ultralow threshold silicon detectors like Skipper CCDs can measure ionization down to individual electron hole pairs, making them exquisitely sensitive to these reduced signals [AG 2024.12 1403]. A Skipper CCD array has already been shown to exceed the sensitivity of all existing millicharged particle searches for masses below 1.5 GeV — a concrete demonstration that silicon detectors enhance rather than eliminate discovery potential [AG 2024.12 1403]. The challenge is not that fractional charges are invisible; it's that distinguishing them from backgrounds (cosmic rays, beam induced noise) requires careful detector design and simulation. Why the ionization spectrum matters Recent work has shown that including collective effects in the silicon material response — the excitation of bulk plasmons — shifts the recoil ionization spectrum toward higher energies, typically peaking around 4–6 electron hole pairs [AG 2024.02 1255]. This more accurate model helps refine what signals to expect and makes detection feasible with dedicated, well calibrated experiments. The current experimental landscape Rather than ruling out fractional charges, multiple dedicated searches are now underway or proposed: LANSCE mQ at Los Alamos [AG 2024.07 737], FORMOSA at the LHC [AG 2025.04 1532], Jefferson Lab beam dump experiments [AG 2024.12 1403], and even repurposed Cavendish electrostatic tests [AG 2025.10 1649]. This active experimental investment reflects confidence that silicon and scintillator detectors can probe fractional charge phase space that was previously inaccessible.