Could environmental effects like dark matter density suppress scalarization selectively in the LIGO mass range?

# Dark Matter, Scalarization, and LIGO's Mass Window

Your question is asking something genuinely interesting: whether a high local density of dark matter could selectively *suppress* scalarization in the LIGO mass range (roughly 10–100 solar masses). Let me work through what the archive tells us.

The Mass-Window Picture

The key insight comes from [AG-2025.05-311]. In scalar-tensor theories where a scalar field couples to the Gauss-Bonnet invariant, supermassive black holes *should* scalarize generically — but LIGO/VIRGO constraints show they don't. The resolution is a narrow "window": scalarization can occur only within specific mass ranges, leaving LIGO sources unaffected while allowing supermassive black holes to scalarize elsewhere. This window is set by the coupling length scale λ.

The question of environmental *suppression* is harder to answer directly from these papers.

What the Archive Says About Environmental Effects

Several papers study how scalar environments affect binaries:

• [AG-2025.10-408] develops waveform models for binaries in scalar environments and finds that light scalar fields *alter* binary dynamics, though the effects in the LIGO catalog are subtle.

• [AG-2025.10-466] simulates black-hole mergers immersed in scalar field overdensities and finds binaries can undergo *delayed or accelerated* mergers — the environment *enhances* gravitational effects in some regimes, not suppresses them.

• [AG-2025.10-455] studies scalar dark matter around neutron star binaries and finds that scalar clouds can form and remain bound, again *modifying* dynamics rather than erasing scalarization.

The Honest Answer

None of these papers directly address whether dark matter density could suppress scalarization selectively in the LIGO mass range. The existing work focuses on how environmental scalar fields *enhance* or alter waveforms; the suppression or triggering of scalarization itself (via the coupling mechanism) appears to be determined by the intrinsic mass and coupling scale λ, not by local dark matter density.

That said, [AG-2025.05-311] notes that "environmental interactions" could mimic scalarization signatures, so there's room for a subtle story — but the archive doesn't develop it for your specific scenario.