Antigravity Q&A
How do cluster merger timescales in MOND simulations compare to observed galaxy collision rates?
Answered by claude-haiku-4-5 · 3 May 2026
Answer
Your question asks specifically about MOND simulations of cluster merger timescales. Unfortunately, the preprints provided don't contain MOND-based dynamical simulations of mergers to compare against observations.
What *is* available here:
On observed/simulated merger timescales generally: [AG-2025.04-063] characterizes galaxy merger timescales in IllustrisTNG (a standard ΛCDM hydrodynamical simulation), finding that timescales depend strongly on host halo mass and orbital parameters, with a fitting formula accurate to ~0.15 dex scatter. This provides an observational benchmark, but uses Newtonian gravity, not MOND.
On MOND and clusters: [AG-2024.10-060] discusses MOND's well-known failure in galaxy clusters, showing that MOND leaves a "residual missing mass problem" requiring an additional dark component with a specific density profile (inner core + outer steep power law). However, this paper characterizes the *static* mass distribution needed to match lensing data—it doesn't simulate cluster collision dynamics or merger timescales under MOND.
On cluster mergers more broadly: [AG-2025.04-055] and [AG-2025.05-043] analyze merger shock evolution and mass assembly histories in ΛCDM simulations, but again not MOND.
The archive does not contain MOND-based N-body or hydrodynamical simulations that directly address whether cluster merger timescales differ under MOND dynamics compared to observations—that gap would need to be filled by new work.
Sources · 8
- 66%astro-ph.GADescribing the Nonuniversal Galaxy Merger Timescales in IllustrisTNG: Effects of Host Halo Mass, Baryons, and Sample SelectionAG-2025.04-063
- 64%astro-ph.COHydrodynamical simulations of merging galaxy clusters: giant dark matter particle colliders, powered by gravityAG-2024.04-980
- 62%astro-ph.COOn the nature of the missing mass of galaxy clusters in MOND: the view from gravitational lensingAG-2024.10-060
- 62%astro-ph.GAIntra-Cluster Light as a Dynamical Clock for Galaxy Clusters: Insights from the MAGNETICUM, IllustrisTNG, Hydrangea and Horizon-AGN SimulationsAG-2025.03-371
- 62%astro-ph.GAThe Milky Way accretion history compared to cosmological simulations -- from bulge to dwarf galaxy infallAG-2024.11-181
- 61%astro-ph.COThe eventful life journey of galaxy clusters. I. Impact of DM halo and ICM properties on their full assembly historiesAG-2025.05-043
- 61%astro-ph.COThe rise and fall of radio-luminous merger shocks from a large sample of galaxy cluster simulationsAG-2025.04-055
- 61%astro-ph.COGalaxy Mergers in a Fractal CosmologyAG-2025.04-196
Keep exploring
This is a research aid — not a peer review. Verify sources before citing.