How would galaxy cluster dynamics differ if MOND operated at cosmic expansion scales instead?

This is an imaginative counterfactual question, but the preprints don't directly address what would happen if MOND's modification activated at cosmic expansion scales rather than at the galactic acceleration threshold.

That said, I can sketch what the archives tell us about MOND's current scope and failures, which constrains the thought experiment.

MOND's present scale and limitations

MOND works by postulating that gravity deviates from Newton's law below a critical acceleration $a_0 \approx 10^{-10}$ m/s² [AG-2025.02-355]. At this tiny threshold, observed accelerations follow $a_{\text{obs}} = \sqrt{a_{\text{Newtonian}} \cdot a_0}$ rather than the Newtonian prediction [AG-2025.01-283]. This elegantly explains flat galactic rotation curves without invoking dark matter.

But MOND fails catastrophically in galaxy clusters [AG-2025.05-332]. The residual missing mass in clusters far exceeds what MOND predicts, leaving roughly a 10:1 ratio of unexplained to explained dynamics [AG-2024.10-060]. Even recent attempts to extend MOND's field equations to clusters still cannot fully account for the missing mass [AG-2026.02-201].

Why cosmic scales would be even worse

The accelerations at play during cosmic expansion—driven by the Hubble flow—are vastly *larger* than $a_0$. The expansion rate $H_0 \approx 70$ km/s/Mpc translates to accelerations of order $10^{-18}$ m/s² at megaparsec scales, which is far below MOND's threshold. If MOND's transition were instead tuned to cosmic scales, it would remain in the Newtonian regime throughout all galactic and cluster dynamics. This would resurrect the original dark matter problem MOND was designed to solve.

Conversely, if you somehow made MOND activate at expansion scales, you'd be proposing a modification that only turns on when accelerations drop below $\sim 10^{-18}$ m/s²—meaning it would have *no* effect on the dynamics of individual galaxies or clusters, where observed accelerations are much larger. Galaxy clusters would still require dark matter, and galaxy rotation curves would still need dark matter, defeating the purpose of MOND as a unified explanation.

None of the provided preprints explore this reversed-scale scenario.