Why does thermal noise dominate LIGO's budget while shot noise limits LISA, changing where squeezing helps most?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

The fundamental reason lies in how these two detectors couple to their noise sources and how their noise scales with frequency.

LIGO's thermal noise problem:

LIGO operates as a kilometer-scale ground-based interferometer. Its test masses—the mirrors that measure gravitational waves—are suspended and free to move. At low frequencies (below ~100 Hz), thermal vibrations of the suspension system and the mirrors themselves dominate the noise budget [AG-2024.04-408]. This thermal noise is *classical* and independent of the quantum properties of light; it comes from random jiggling of atoms in the optics and suspension. Thermal noise couples equally at all frequencies and doesn't decrease with higher laser power, so it sets a fundamental floor on sensitivity below certain frequencies.

LISA's shot noise limitation:

LISA, by contrast, operates in space where thermal noise is negligible. As a laser interferometer that measures distance changes via photon counting, LISA's sensitivity is limited by *shot noise*—the quantum fluctuations in the number of photons received at the detector [AG-2025.09-387]. Shot noise decreases when you use more photons, but LISA operates at millihertz frequencies where thermal effects vanish and the photon-counting noise becomes the binding constraint [AG-2026.01-520].

Where squeezing helps:

Squeezing—a quantum state of light that trades uncertainty in one variable for another—addresses *quantum* noise (shot noise and radiation pressure noise), not classical thermal noise [AG-2024.04-408]. For LIGO, squeezing reduces quantum noise below the Standard Quantum Limit, but only in frequency bands where quantum noise competes with thermal noise; below ~10 Hz, thermal noise is so dominant that squeezing provides limited benefit [AG-2024.04-408]. For LISA, which has no competing thermal noise across its band, broadband quantum-noise suppression via frequency-dependent squeezing delivers sensitivity gains across the entire millihertz band [AG-2024.01-1430].

In essence: LIGO fights a classical demon (atoms vibrating), so quantum tricks help but don't solve the core problem. LISA fights a quantum demon (photon counting), so quantum engineering like squeezing is directly addressing its fundamental limit.