Why would cosmological models with paired positive-negative mass remain dynamically unstable even with coupling?

# On the instability of paired positive-negative mass cosmologies

The fundamental issue is that positive and negative masses naturally repel each other gravitationally — they don't form a stable bound state — and this repulsion destabilizes any configuration trying to mix them together, even when you add coupling mechanisms to try to hold them in place.

The core instability mechanism

In a universe containing equal amounts of positive mass (ordinary matter) and negative mass, a linear stability analysis reveals that mixed configurations are inherently unstable [AG-2026.01-618]. The physical reason is straightforward: positive masses attract each other, negative masses attract each other, but a positive mass repels a negative mass. This creates an imbalance. When you perturb such a system — say, by slightly increasing the density of positive mass in one region — the positive masses there attract each other more strongly while simultaneously repelling nearby negative masses outward. The system spontaneously segregates, with growth rates that accelerate at smaller and smaller scales [AG-2026.01-618].

Why coupling doesn't solve it

You might imagine that introducing a coupling interaction — a force that binds positive and negative masses together — could stabilize things. The research shows it doesn't, at least not durably. In the Bondi universe model, even when positive and negative masses are coupled through gravitational collisions (Bondi encounters), the system still undergoes dynamic evolution [AG-2026.01-618]. The coupling actually *accelerates* the instability by driving the system toward strong interactions, at which point positive-negative mass pairs form and separate from the bulk fluid — the mixed state fragments rather than equilibrates [AG-2026.01-618].

The deeper lesson comes from classical general relativity itself: any barotropic model (one where pressure is a simple function of density) containing negative mass is dynamically unstable, without appeal to quantum effects or energy conditions [AG-2024.07-629]. This suggests the instability is baked into the geometry and fluid dynamics, not a quirk of particular coupling schemes.

One possible escape: bound pairs

Interestingly, stable configurations *can* form — but only as isolated bound pairs of one positive and one negative mass object, not as a mixed cosmological fluid [AG-2026.02-280]. A positive mass object can indeed orbit or be bound to a nearby negative mass object despite the repulsion, because their centers of mass remain fixed in space. But this requires local structure, not a uniform coupled mixture.

---

The preprints don't directly address whether *other types of coupling* (beyond gravitational and collisional) might alter this conclusion, though the stability argument from general relativity alone suggests the problem is deep.