Why does the equivalence principle violation show up in redshift-velocity dispersion mismatches rather than in lensing observations?

This is a thoughtful question that gets at the different *sensitivities* of gravitational probes to equivalence principle (EP) violations.

Why redshift-velocity dispersion mismatches are more revealing

The key insight is that gravitational redshift and velocity dispersion probe the gravitational potential through different physical mechanisms [AG-2026.01-524].

Gravitational redshift measures the *depth* of a gravitational potential well directly: photons lose energy climbing out of it, and this energy loss depends on the actual gravitational potential. Velocity dispersion, by contrast, reflects how fast particles are moving—which depends on how they *accelerate* in response to gravity.

If dark matter couples to a fifth force in addition to gravity, or if its inertial mass differs from its gravitational mass, the two measurements will diverge [AG-2026.01-524]. Dark matter particles might fall differently than ordinary matter in the potential well, showing up as a mismatch: the redshift says "the potential is deep," but the velocity dispersion says "particles aren't moving as fast as they should be." This mismatch is a clean signature of EP violation.

Why lensing observations are less sensitive

Gravitational lensing depends only on the *total* gravitational potential—it bends light according to the combined spacetime curvature from all matter, whether ordinary or dark [AG-2024.04-266]. A fifth force that affects dark matter differently would still bend light the same way overall, because lensing is insensitive to how matter *accelerates*; it only cares about the integrated potential gradient along the light path.

This creates a fundamental degeneracy: models with modified gravity and models with a dark force coupling to dark matter can produce *identical* lensing signals [AG-2024.04-266]. Redshift-space distortions (which depend on velocity) suffer the same problem. Only by including the gravitational redshift test—which directly probes the potential—can you break this degeneracy and isolate whether dark matter is being treated differently [AG-2024.04-266].

In short: lensing is "blind" to how matter accelerates, so it cannot distinguish an EP violation from a gravitational modification. Redshift measurements, combined with dynamics, can.