How do horizonless objects like boson stars alter photon orbits compared to classical black holes?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Photon Orbits Around Boson Stars vs. Black Holes The key difference is that boson stars, being horizonless, allow photons to penetrate deep into the spacetime in ways forbidden around black holes—yet some configurations can mimic black hole behavior so closely that they're nearly indistinguishable observationally. The Fundamental Difference A classical black hole traps photons at the event horizon: light can enter but never escape, creating a sharp boundary. Boson stars have no such boundary [AG 2025.03 707]. Instead, they possess what's called a "critical horizon"—a region where the spacetime geometry transitions sharply but photons can in principle traverse it. This means photons can orbit throughout the entire boson star spacetime , including its interior [AG 2025.03 707]. Frozen Boson Stars: The Black Hole Imposters The most striking finding is that certain boson stars—"frozen" ones with very low oscillation frequency—produce photon orbits that nearly replicate black hole behavior [AG 2025.03 707]. Near their critical horizon, photons exhibit "sharp deflections," resembling the dramatic light bending around a black hole. Yet inside that critical region, something strange happens: from the perspective of a distant observer, photons appear to linger for extraordinarily long times, as if trapped [AG 2025.03 707]. Multiple Light Rings vs. Single Photon Sphere Here's where they diverge observationally. A classical black hole is guaranteed to have exactly one photon sphere—a stable bound photon orbit—which appears as a single bright ring in images [AG 2024.05 275]. Non frozen boson stars, by contrast, generate multiple photon rings within the shadow region because photons can orbit the object multiple times at different radii before escaping [AG 2025.07 260]. In strong coupling regimes (where the scalar field couples tightly to spacetime), ray tracing simulations reveal "nested sub annuli within the Einstein ring" and higher order lensing patterns absent in black hole shadows [AG 2025.02 675]. Frozen boson stars, however, suppress these interior rings and produce images nearly identical to Schwarzschild black holes [AG 2025.07 260]—a challenge for distinguishing them observationally. Why This Matters The absence of a horizon means boson stars lack the thermodynamic and information theoretic properties of black holes. Observationally, the difference hinges on very long baseline interferometry: if you could image the finest details of a compact object's light ring and found no signature of multiple rings or exotic lensing patterns, you'd have strong evidence against a black hole [AG 2024.05 275]. Conversely, some boson stars are such good mimickers that distinguishing them requires analyzing the structure of lensing bands and the effective potential landscape rather than shadow morphology alone [AG 2025.09 451].