Could differences in dynamical relaxation between cluster and galactic environments alter the acceleration regimes that RAR measurements probe?

Your question cuts to something genuinely subtle: whether the *dynamical environment* itself—not just the gravitational regime—can shift what the Radial Acceleration Relation (RAR) is actually measuring.

The short answer from the archive: yes, cluster and galactic environments do reveal *different* RAR behaviors, but the mechanism appears to be a genuine difference in the underlying gravitational physics rather than just relaxation timescales masking the same physics.

The cluster-galaxy RAR divergence

Galaxies obey a tight RAR: the observed acceleration (inferred from rotation curves or velocity dispersions) correlates predictably with the acceleration from baryonic mass alone [AG-2025.04-423]. This is the empirical foundation for both dark-matter and modified-gravity explanations. However, galaxy clusters *don't* follow the same RAR [AG-2026.02-201]. This isn't noise—it's a systematic departure.

The key finding is that modified-gravity theories (AQUAL, GRAS, MOND variants) that fit galactic RAR data beautifully *fail* on clusters [AG-2026.02-201]. The authors developed a modified field equation with a single free parameter that can unify both regimes, suggesting the difference is not merely environmental scatter but a reflection of how gravity itself operates at different scales.

Dynamical state as a secondary effect

You might expect that relaxation differences—clusters are often dynamically disturbed, galaxies more settled—would blur the RAR in clusters. But the evidence suggests this isn't the dominant issue. Work on cluster dynamical states [AG-2025.04-272] shows that whether a cluster is relaxed or disturbed does *not* significantly alter fundamental relations among its member galaxies, nor their mean properties. This implies that dynamical state is a higher-order effect on these scaling relations.

Tests of alternative gravity theories in clusters (e.g., Refracted Gravity [AG-2024.10-497]) find that even with high-precision kinematics, different clusters require different parameter values, again pointing to a genuine physical difference between environments rather than just relaxation smearing the same universal relation.

Why it matters

This suggests the RAR is not a single universal law that relaxation or environment perturbs—it's environment-dependent by design. Any theory claiming to explain dark matter or modify gravity must account for why galaxies and clusters live in different corners of acceleration space, not just fit the scatter within each.

The provided preprints do directly address your question: they show cluster and galactic RAR differences are real and systematically different, though they focus on the gravitational-theory explanation rather than explicitly disentangling dynamical relaxation from fundamental physics.