Can a timelike worldline become spacelike under coordinate transformation without violating causality?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Can a timelike worldline become spacelike under coordinate transformation? No—not without breaking the mathematics of relativity itself. Here's why: A worldline's causal character (whether it's timelike, spacelike, or null) is an invariant property: it depends only on the spacetime geometry, not on how you label points. Think of it like the distance between two cities—whether you measure in kilometers or miles, Boston and New York are still about 200 miles apart. More precisely, the causal type of a worldline is determined by the sign of the spacetime interval $ds^2$ between nearby points on it. In any coordinate system, if $ds^2 < 0$ (using the mostly plus signature convention), the path is timelike; if $ds^2 0$, it's spacelike. A coordinate transformation is just a relabeling—it rescales $dx$, $dy$, $dz$, $dt$ in different ways, but it cannot flip the sign of $ds^2$ for the same geometric curve. Why this matters for causality: If timelike worldlines could become spacelike under relabeling, causality would be meaningless—you could transform away violations of causality by choosing a different coordinate system. The whole edifice of relativity, which separates "what can influence what," would collapse. That said, coordinate transformations can expose hidden causal pathologies in spacetimes with exotic topology or identifications. For instance, identifications in the extended Reissner–Nordström spacetime can create situations where closed timelike curves become possible—not because a worldline changed type, but because new causal connections emerge from the global structure [AG 2024.08 499], [AG 2025.02 458]. Similarly, the Gödel universe admits coordinate independent closed timelike curves throughout [AG 2025.10 347], and some spacetimes are acausal no matter what coordinates you use [AG 2025.01 331]. The provided preprints don't directly address the theoretical mechanics of why coordinate transformations preserve causal type.