Would detectors optimized for the 4–6 pair window miss millicharged particles with different ionization signatures entirely?

Your question touches on a real tension in detector design: yes, detectors tuned to the 4–6 electron-hole pair window could in principle miss millicharged particles if those particles produce distinctly different ionization spectra.

Here's why this matters: The 4–6 pair window isn't arbitrary. Recent calculations [AG-2024.02-1255] show that when relativistic particles scatter in silicon, including the full quantum response of the material (collective plasmon excitations), the ionization spectrum peaks around 4–6 pairs—*substantially higher* than older, simpler models predicted. A detector optimized for that sweet spot gains sensitivity to the most probable events.

But the catch is "most probable" ≠ "all possible." Millicharged particles have a tunable parameter space: their charge can range across many orders of magnitude, and their masses span from sub-MeV to GeV scales. If a millicharged particle's charge, mass, or velocity differs enough from the benchmark case, its ionization signature could shift. A particle scattering at a different angle, or with different kinetic energy, might produce 2–3 pairs or 10–15 pairs instead—and if your detector's threshold or efficiency is sharp at the 4–6 window, you'd miss those events.

The practical answer: **Current proposals use *multiple* detection modalities or broad energy acceptance specifically to avoid this blind spot.** For instance, the Skipper-CCD approach [AG-2024.12-1403] achieves sensitivity to millicharged particles by virtue of an ultralow threshold (detecting single-electron excitations), not by tuning to a narrow window—so it captures the full spectrum. Similarly, accelerator-based searches like FORMOSA [AG-2025.04-1532] employ scintillator-based detectors, which have a different response and can cover a wider signal space.

The archival papers don't directly address whether a 4–6-pair-optimized detector would systematically miss specific charge or mass ranges of millicharged particles.