How precisely do thermal nonequilibrium and material inhomogeneity differ in their contribution to the net force?

# Thermal Nonequilibrium vs. Material Inhomogeneity in Self-Propulsion

These are fundamentally different mechanisms, and the archive shows they operate at different orders of a systematic quantum expansion—which matters for predicting which effect dominates in real systems.

The Key Distinction

Thermal nonequilibrium means the object is at a different temperature than its environment (or the blackbody radiation background). Material inhomogeneity means different parts of the object have different electromagnetic properties—for instance, a sphere made of two different substances glued together.

Here's the critical finding: thermal nonequilibrium alone is *necessary but not sufficient* for a net force to arise [AG-2024.11-890]. The reason is subtle: an out-of-equilibrium object emits asymmetric thermal radiation, which creates an asymptotic radiation pattern. But the mathematics of how this translates into force depends on the material structure [AG-2024.05-941].

Order-by-Order Contributions

When you expand the propulsive force in powers of electric susceptibility (how strongly the material polarizes), the two effects appear at different orders:

• First order: A spontaneous *torque* can appear, but only if the material is nonreciprocal—meaning it breaks time-reversal symmetry (typically requiring an external magnetic field). No force arises at first order, even out of equilibrium [AG-2024.11-890].

• Second order: A spontaneous *force* appears, but now the material need only be inhomogeneous—it can be made of ordinary, reciprocal materials [AG-2024.05-941]. Thermal nonequilibrium is still required as the driver.

In plain terms: inhomogeneity is the *structure* that lets a thermal gradient generate force, while thermal nonequilibrium is the *fuel*. Together they produce a net force; separately they produce nothing useful [AG-2024.05-941].

Practical Implication

The authors tested this on four geometries: a needle of two different halves, hemispheric spheres of different materials, and asymmetric slabs [AG-2024.05-941]. All showed consistent second-order forces, demonstrating that you don't need exotic nonreciprocal materials—ordinary inhomogeneous composites suffice. This matters because it makes experimental observation far more realistic.

Higher-order terms may relax the inhomogeneity requirement altogether [AG-2024.11-890], but second order is where the physics becomes accessible.