Why does imposing different asymptotic boundary conditions change which fermionic operators are physically allowed?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Boundary Conditions and the Constraints on Fermionic Operators Your question touches on a deep principle: asymptotic boundary conditions encode global topological information that determines which local operators can consistently exist in a quantum theory. The Core Mechanism When you specify how fields must behave at infinity (or at other boundaries), you're not just choosing a coordinate system—you're selecting a consistent superselection sector of the theory. Different boundary conditions correspond to different ways of "closing off" the infinite volume, and these closures have different topological properties [AG 2024.04 164, AG 2025.10 337]. In field theory, fermionic operators carry subtle quantum numbers; some of these are global symmetries (like fermion parity), while others are anomalous —they can't exist consistently in all configurations of the background fields. The key insight from [AG 2025.09 703] is that fermionic unitary operators behave anomalously under position dependent symmetry transformations when the spatial topology winds in particular ways. For instance, a $U(1)$ gauge transformation at odd winding number becomes fermionic —it anticommutes with itself rather than commuting—precisely because the boundary conditions force a specific global structure on the theory. This is not a quirk of the math; it's a real physical constraint encoded in the allowed spectrum. Operator Dimension Parity A complementary view appears in [AG 2024.02 535]: if a fermionic quantum field theory admits a basis where all operators have even dimension, this imposes a $\mathbb{Z} 4$ symmetry that mixes operator dimension parity with fermion number parity. Asymptotic boundary conditions that don't respect this mixed parity rule out certain operators—they have odd dimension in any basis consistent with the boundary physics. The result: boundary conditions and operator content become mutually constraining. Why This Matters Understanding which operators are "really there" is essential for phenomenology: [AG 2024.02 535] shows this principle can severely restrict baryon and lepton number violating processes in extensions of the Standard Model, simply by enforcing the right global topology at infinity. None of these preprints directly explain asymptotic boundary conditions in fermionic theories (they focus on finite boundaries, gauge anomalies, and dimension parity separately), so a more unified treatment would strengthen this answer.