Could scalar field overdensities around LIGO sources actually *trigger* rather than suppress scalarization?

Your question points to a genuinely subtle physics scenario. Let me unpack what the archive shows.

The Standard Picture: Overdensity as Suppression

In most scalar-tensor gravity theories, the conventional expectation is that a *high* density environment suppresses scalarization. The scalar field couples to matter through an effective charge, and in dense regions, the field gets "screened"—roughly like electrostatic shielding—preventing the scalar degree of freedom from activating. This is why LIGO sources (stellar-mass black holes) don't scalarize significantly even in theories that allow it for supermassive black holes [AG-2025.05-311].

The Triggering Mechanism: A Narrower Path

However, the preprints reveal something more nuanced. In numerical simulations of black hole binaries *immersed in scalar field overdensities*, researchers found that binaries can undergo either delayed or accelerated mergers compared to vacuum [AG-2025.10-466]. This isn't classical scalarization of the black holes themselves; instead, the pre-existing scalar overdensity acts dynamically—it extracts orbital energy and angular momentum, altering the binary's trajectory.

More directly relevant to your intuition: in scalar-tensor theories with Gauss-Bonnet coupling, scalarization can occur within a "narrow window of masses" [AG-2025.05-311], and environmental interactions (including scalar overdensities) may shift the conditions under which a system tips into or out of the scalarized branch. The scalar field around a compact object isn't purely a passive backdrop; it couples back to the binary's dynamics.

Why This Matters

If overdensities can *accelerate* mergers or alter the parameter space where scalarization becomes thermodynamically favored, it flips the naive picture: a dense scalar environment might not simply damp the phenomenon but could reshape *when and how* it occurs. This has real consequences for gravitational-wave signals and, by extension, for what LIGO data might tell us about modified gravity.

That said, the preprints don't directly demonstrate a case where an overdensity *initiates* scalarization in a system that would remain unscalarized in vacuum—only that overdensities modify dynamics significantly and can shift the effective threshold.