Does chaos in Tomimatsu–Sato orbits emerge gradually as multipole deformation increases, or suddenly?

# Chaos in Tomimatsu–Sato Orbits: Gradual or Sudden?

The preprints provided don't directly address Tomimatsu–Sato spacetimes or how chaos emerges specifically in their orbits as multipole deformation increases.

However, I can sketch what we know from closely related systems. The Kerr-like metric (which shares the deformation structure of Tomimatsu–Sato geometries) shows that when a quadrupole deformation parameter $q_{\mathrm{KL}} \neq 0$ is introduced, the Carter constant—which normally ensures integrability—ceases to exist, making orbits chaotic [AG-2026.01-636]. This suggests the loss of integrability is *discontinuous* at $q = 0$ in principle, though the practical onset of detectable chaos may be gradual.

A more revealing pattern comes from analogous systems: in Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetime, Poincaré sections show regular KAM (Kolmogorov-Arnold-Moser) tori when parameters are far from criticality, but "distortions and chaos emerge as they converge," with Lyapunov exponents growing smoothly as the control parameter changes [AG-2025.02-611]. Similarly, in galaxies with prolate halos plus a spinning black hole, the Maximum Lyapunov Exponent reveals how chaos is "modulated" smoothly by the spin [AG-2026.01-203].

The pattern across these systems suggests a gradual emergence: the threshold for integrability breaking is sharp (loss of a conserved constant), but the *degree* of chaos, quantified by Lyapunov exponents, typically increases continuously as deformation grows.

The archive does not contain a direct Tomimatsu–Sato analysis with varying multipole moments.