Why does MOND fail so dramatically on galaxy clusters compared to galaxies?

Why MOND Fails in Galaxy Clusters

MOND works beautifully for individual galaxies—it explains their flat rotation curves without invoking dark matter [AG-2025.05-332]—but it hits a wall at the scale of galaxy clusters. The core problem is simple: even after applying MOND's modified gravity rules, clusters still have a substantial "missing mass" problem [AG-2024.10-060].

### The Scale Problem

The key difference is *acceleration*. MOND modifies gravity specifically in the low-acceleration regime [AG-2025.01-283]. In a galaxy's outer regions, stars orbit at very low accelerations, triggering MOND's modifications. But galaxy clusters are so massive that the internal accelerations are higher—pushing them closer to the regime where Newtonian gravity dominates [AG-2025.05-332]. In this intermediate acceleration zone, MOND doesn't modify gravity enough to account for the observed dynamics, leaving a residual missing-mass problem [AG-2024.10-060].

### What's Missing?

Using gravitational lensing data from the CLASH survey, researchers find that the "missing" matter in clusters has a distinctive structure: a constant-density core in the inner ~1 Mpc, with a steep outer profile [AG-2024.10-060]. Remarkably, the ratio of this residual mass to the hot gas density is uniform across clusters (~10:1), suggesting a real physical component rather than a model artifact. Intriguingly, this missing mass could potentially be explained by cold molecular gas, neutrinos, or other non-luminous particles—ironically reintroducing hidden matter through the back door [AG-2024.08-251].

### Theoretical Tensions

There's also a deeper internal inconsistency in MOND itself. The Solar System's quadrupole moment constrains how sharply gravity must transition from the MOND regime to Newtonian gravity—but this requirement conflicts with the transition sharpness inferred from galaxies' rotation curves by roughly 8.7 standard deviations [AG-2024.01-118]. MOND can't simultaneously satisfy all three anchors: galaxy rotation curves, Solar System precision tests, and cluster dynamics.

### Ongoing Work

Some researchers are developing generalized versions of MOND-like theories that might work across scales. A modified version of GRAS/AQUAL theory with a single new parameter shows promise in reconciling galaxies and clusters [AG-2026.02-201], and relativistic frameworks like Hyperconical Modified Gravity are being tested against high-resolution X-ray cluster data [AG-2024.08-251]. But as of now, no single modification of Newtonian gravity has cracked all three astrophysical regimes simultaneously.