Can we experimentally distinguish entropic gravity's temperature-dependent MOND from other relativistic MOND variants?

Question

Antigravity · Accepted Answer

Distinguishing Entropic Gravity's Temperature Dependent MOND This is an excellent question—and the honest answer is that the preprints show the problem is subtler than it appears. The Core Issue: Multiple Entropy Functions, One MOND Outcome The entropic gravity approach produces MOND like dynamics from the holographic principle and Unruh thermodynamics. The surprise: it's not unique to one entropy formula. [AG 2024.06 070] demonstrates that MOND emerges from a family of non Boltzmann–Gibbs entropies—Kaniadakis, Tsallis–Rényi, and others—all yielding roughly the same phenomenology when combined with the equipartition law on a holographic screen. This creates an immediate challenge: if multiple entropy functions produce indistinguishable MOND behavior at galactic scales, how do we test the temperature dependent version specifically? What Makes the Temperature Variant Distinct? [AG 2025.11 149] is the key paper here. It derives a relativistic MOND by building thermal corrections into the equipartition law itself—not just using an exotic entropy formula, but explicitly temperature dependent geometric modifications to Einstein's equations. This is different from the non relativistic entropic derivations and from other relativistic MOND variants [AG 2026.01 159], which use algebraic or conformal symmetry principles instead. The temperature dependent version should, in principle, produce: Thermal corrections to the metric that scale with background temperature or acceleration induced Unruh temperature Deviations at intermediate accelerations (not just the deep MOND regime) if the system's effective temperature varies Different predictions in extreme environments : near black hole horizons, in the early universe, or in systems with high particle velocities where Unruh effects are non negligible How To Distinguish Them Experimentally Three approaches emerge (though the preprints don't detail full experiments): 1. Multi regime galaxy dynamics : [AG 2025.11 149] fits NGC 3198 rotation curves as well as dark matter, but the shape of the transition from Newtonian to MOND regimes depends sensitively on the thermal correction function. Precision rotation curve measurements across multiple galaxies at different redshifts could reveal whether the interpolation function is universal (as plain MOND assumes) or temperature dependent. 2. Cosmological signatures : [AG 2025.12 255] shows that nonlocal MOND models unify galactic and cosmological scales. A temperature dependent entropic variant would predict modifications to the early universe (where effective Unruh temperatures are higher) that differ from field theory or conformal symmetry based MOND [AG 2026.01 159]. The CMB power spectrum and structure formation rates could show distinctive imprints. 3. Tabletop quantum gravity tests : [AG 2024.12 518] proposes measuring gravity's quantization via macroscopic thermodynamical observables (heat capacity of a gravitationally self interacting Bose gas). A temperature dependent entropic gravity theory would predict measurable heat capacity anomalies absent in other MOND variants—a way to probe the Unruh temperature coupling directly in a controlled lab setting. The Uncomfortable Truth The preprints do not provide a detailed experimental roadmap for this discrimination. The entropic gravity framework's flexibility—the fact that many entropy functions yield MOND [AG 2024.06 070]—means we lack a clean, unique "smoking gun" test. Most existing observational tests (galaxy rotation curves, weak lensing) will struggle to distinguish among the variants because they all aim to match the same low acceleration phenomenology. The distinguishing power likely lies in extreme regimes : high redshift galaxies (where thermal history matters), precision tests near black holes, or quantum gravity signatures in tabletop experiments—regions where different entropy functions predict measurably different temperature dependence.