Why must the coupling function silence the scalar field near black holes but not in cosmology?

Your question asks about a tension that appears across modified gravity theories: why does the scalar field need to be suppressed at black holes but not in cosmological settings?

The short answer is that black holes and cosmology impose opposite demands on scalar fields through their geometric and boundary conditions [AG-2024.03-382].

The black hole problem

In scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity—a popular modification of general relativity where a scalar field couples to spacetime curvature—the same mechanism that gives black holes scalar "hair" (an extra layer of structure) makes them incompatible with a cosmological horizon [AG-2024.03-382]. The coupling that creates this hair is too rigid: it forces the scalar field to behave in a way that cannot smoothly match to an expanding universe. To resolve this, you need an extra term in the theory that fundamentally alters the black hole's properties, including drastically changing its hair [AG-2024.03-382].

Why? Black holes have an event horizon with a fixed boundary condition. A scalar field that couples strongly to curvature will inevitably accumulate near the horizon, destabilizing the solution when you try to connect it to a time-dependent cosmological background [AG-2024.03-382].

The cosmology solution

By contrast, in cosmological backgrounds, scalar fields representing dark energy *can* reach stable configurations even near black holes, because the expanding universe provides a different boundary condition at infinity [AG-2024.08-389]. The field has room to adjust its behavior: it converges to a finite, stable energy density inside the event horizon while remaining continuous and bounded at the horizon itself [AG-2024.08-389]. This works precisely because the cosmological expansion decouples the local black hole dynamics from rigid boundary constraints.

The coupling's role

The coupling function must therefore be designed to "silence" the scalar field near black holes—that is, suppress its interaction with curvature locally—while allowing it to remain active on cosmological scales where the expansion of the universe naturally regularizes the field's behavior [AG-2024.03-382]. This is not a bug but a feature: theories that achieve this (like scalar-tensor models with time-dependent scalars) can accommodate both black holes and cosmological horizons [AG-2024.03-382].

In essence, the coupling must be *context-sensitive*: weak enough locally to preserve black hole solutions, but structured to match the time-dependence of cosmology globally.